I’ve had several conversations about thought leadership in the last year. Most of them start with a definition question: what is it, exactly? I’ve written about my answer before, and I don’t want to go around that loop again. What keeps coming up is something narrower and more useful: the difference between being a leader and being an authority.

They get used as synonyms. They aren’t.

Followers Are the Test

Someone who puts a thought into another person’s mind that they would not have had otherwise, and that person uses it to take their next step or become a little better, has led someone. That’s the whole test.

If someone presents themselves as a thought leader and has no followers, are they leading? I don’t mean followers in the social media sense. I mean people who took the thought, applied it, and got results. People who feel better equipped for the work in front of them because of something you shared.

If nobody is applying your thoughts, you may be presenting yourself as a leader with no followers. It’s a strange position to occupy, and a common one.

Authority Is Relative to the Room

Many people believe they can’t be thought leaders unless they’re authorities first. Experts. The people who know the topic best.

I don’t think that’s true. Authority is relative to the audience in front of you.

Depending on where an audience is, what their context is, and what they need to get done, the person a few steps ahead of them can be their authority. That person can help them get where they’re going. Outside that room, they may not be an authority at all. Ask whether they’re a reference in the industry, whether their peers point other people to their work, whether their content gets shared without them pushing it.

I’ve watched people rate themselves a six out of six on a topic and declare themselves an authority. Then the questions come: have you written something on it? Have you published an essay, given a talk that other people actually use? Is the reputation something you push onto others, or something others hand you unprompted? When the answer is no, the authority is self-assigned. It exists in one head.

An authority without followers isn’t leading anybody. You can be the person who knows the most about a topic and still be leading no one, because nobody is applying what you know.

Authority Is Also a Point in Time

Authority expires.

Being an expert today doesn’t guarantee anything about next year, or five years from now. At the speed things move, plenty of people who were the reference on something stopped being the reference. Sometimes the field moved. Sometimes a tool replaced the craft. Sometimes they just stopped learning.

Years ago, for marketing purposes, people would put “authority in X” on my resume. I never liked it. I knew who I considered the authorities on X, and I wasn’t one of them. Calling myself that would have been inaccurate in a way that was easy for anyone paying attention to catch.

The more I know, the more aware I become of how much I don’t know. That’s not humility theater. It’s what happens when you keep digging into a topic: the surface of your ignorance keeps expanding.

The Pamphlet and the Thousand-Page Book

If authority is about depth, why does the comprehensive thing so often fail to help?

I’d rather read a ten-page pamphlet on a topic than a thousand-page book, if the pamphlet unblocks whatever was keeping me from making progress. Something written for where I am right now, not for the person who will need the exhaustive reference in three years. That pamphlet can make me a little better today. The thousand-page book might make me an expert eventually, or it might sit on the shelf.

A thousand-page book nobody reads, and nobody recommends, doesn’t make its author a reference for anyone. The depth is real, but it isn’t doing anything. A short piece that gets someone moving is doing the work.

Sharing Experiences Instead of Selling Expertise

That’s why I share what I’m learning as I’m learning it. What I tried, whether it worked, and under what constraints.

When something worked, I try to describe the situation it worked in. It may have been the best solution given what I had to achieve at the time, and still not be the right answer for someone else, or for me a year later. When something failed for me, it may work for someone else with a few tweaks, or exactly as it was. Both outcomes are useful to share.

I’m not selling expertise. I’m sharing experiences. I can trace how my own learnings have evolved over the years because I wrote them down as they happened, and that trail is more useful than any single confident answer I could have given.

My blog has worked that way since the beginning. I’ve never used it to sell anything. People have told me that something I shared helped them think about a problem differently. That’s the best outcome I can imagine: not that they think I’m an authority, but that the thought landed and they did something with it.

What I’d Rather Be

I’ve never thought of myself as an authority on anything. I’d rather follow the ideas that move me forward and share the trail as I go, so that someone a few steps behind can use it.

That’s a smaller claim than authority. It’s also one I can back up.

a-follower-not-an-authority.png

Leave a Reply

Trending