I was reading two books at the same time: Seth Godin’s This Is Strategy and Derek Sivers’ Useful, Not True. One morning I was in Derek’s book and thought it would be interesting to sit in a room where Derek and Seth were talking. A moment later, I picked up Seth’s book where I left off and read a chapter. The title of the next one was “The Day I Met Derek Sivers”. It felt like I was watching the conversation happen.

Derek calls Godin one of his mentors, and he tells a story about it.

The email that was just a thank you

There were times when Sivers wanted to ask Godin what he thought about something. Godin is busy. So instead of sending the question, Sivers sat with it and asked himself what Godin would say.

He had read the books and the blog posts. He had gotten advice from Godin before. He knew how Godin thinks. So he worked the problem himself, got to an answer, and realized he did not need to send the question at all.

He emailed Godin anyway, just to say thank you and have a good day.

That is the whole story. A busy mentor, a question that never needed to be asked, and a thank you instead.

What we usually do instead

The default pattern with mentors is a steady stream of questions. What do I do about this? Can you take a look at this?

Asking is fine. The problem is what happens to the mentor. They end up answering the same questions, in slightly different shapes, for people who have not done anything with the last answer.

Sivers checked three things before reaching out:

  • What did they already tell me that applies here?
  • Did I actually do it?
  • What happened when I did?

The first question alone resolves more situations than you would expect. The advice was there. I skimmed it, or I did not understand it at the time, or I decided it did not apply to my situation. Now it does.

What a mentor gets out of it

The second part matters just as much. If I acted on the advice and I have results, the mentor gets something they rarely get: a report from the field. What worked, what did not, what the constraints were, what I would try next.

That turns a question into a contribution. Instead of asking someone to give more, I hand them evidence about the advice they already gave.

Sometimes the answer is that no question is needed at all. The advice was sufficient. I just had not paid close enough attention to it, or I had not understood what it was for. Working that out myself is the learning. Sending the question would have taken that away.

The version I want to be

I want to be the person who shows up with better information, or does not show up at all. Either the mentor’s past advice was enough, and I have proof of what it produced, or I have a question that only they can answer because I have already used what they told me.

It is a small change in habit. A mentor whose advice gets used stays engaged. A mentor who is treated as a search engine eventually stops answering.

So before I open the email, I ask myself the question I was about to ask them. Most of the time, the answer is already in my notes, in something they wrote, or in the last conversation we had. When it is, I send a thank you instead.

answer-the-question-yourself-first.png

Leave a Reply

Trending